What's Next for Prediction Markets?

Prediction markets have surged in popularity over the last few years. It seems like hardly a day goes by that a firm like Kalshi or Polymarket isn't hitting the headlines. While regulation is tightening and lawsuits are piling up, the public appetite for event derivatives doesn't appear to be slowing down. We might well wonder: what's next for the prediction market craze? To answer this question, it's worth first looking back to see how we got here in the first place.
The first major modern breakthrough came in 1988 with the launch of the Iowa Electronic Markets, which demonstrated that small real-money markets could outperform polls in forecasting elections. The project, which is still going, was created for research purposes by the University of Iowa Tippie College of Business.
The early 2000s saw the popularity of prediction markets accelerate, with early online platforms like Intrade. These sites brought event-based trading to the internet before regulatory pressures shut them down.
Things really exploded in the 2020s, when blockchain technology enabled platforms like Augur and Polymarket to offer trustless, automated settlement and global access. This solved the longstanding issues of custody and regulation that previous platforms had been unable to overcome.
Clearer regulatory pathways in the US and renewed public interest in election forecasting pushed prediction markets back into the mainstream. By the mid 2020s, they had evolved from niche academic tools to billion-dollar platforms with millions of users, driven by faster news cycles and the appeal of live, crowd-sourced probabilities.
Prediction markets are now well and truly mainstream. The turning point came in 2024, when regulatory clarity began to emerge in the US. The CFTC moved away from punitive actions toward structured discussions. Kalshi won its lawsuit against the CFTC, which allowed it to relist its election prediction markets. This opened the door for it and its competitors to operate more openly and at a larger scale.
This regulatory thaw was pivotal in allowing prediction markets to gain legitimacy and attract major partners such as Robinhood, UFC, and Yahoo Finance. At the same time, cultural visibility exploded. Kalshi's live market ticker billboard in New York City was seen in person by nearly 13 million people, and prediction markets were even satirized on 'South Park'. Event betting had truly entered the zeitgeist.
Platforms have become more sophisticated and convenient to use, too. Most prediction markets now usually offer apps, allowing users to trade on the go and respond quickly to fast-moving events. As a result, trading activity has surged. Polymarket hit a record number of daily active wallets during the 2024 US election and surpassed $15.7 billion in cumulative volume.
The broader industry reached more than $2 billion in weekly trading by 2025. Markets expanded into even wider niches, including AI, geopolitics, and macro data. Together, the forces of regulatory acceptance, cultural adoption, and massive liquidity had pushed prediction markets to the epicenter of public forecasting.
The future of prediction markets is very much in the hands of the CFTC, as unresolved conflicts remain. Earlier this year, it formally opened a comprehensive regulatory process for event-contract markets, issuing an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking. It also requested public comment on how prediction markets should be governed under federal derivatives law.
This is a significant moment, marking the first time that the agency has attempted to build a unified national framework for prediction markets. Its impact could be far-reaching, affecting how exchanges manage manipulation risks, how event contracts are classified under the Commodity Exchange Act, and which types of contracts are prohibited as contrary to the public interest
While this is happening, the CFTC has also begun asserting more explicit federal jurisdiction. In March of this year, it issued a staff advisory outlining supervisory expectations for Designated Contract Markets listing event contracts. The focus of this advisory is reportedly on sports micro-events, manipulation risk, and the quality of data sources used for settlement. This signals that the CFTC is preparing to treat prediction markets more like traditional derivatives exchanges
The federal push has sparked tensions with state gambling regulators, who argue that many prediction markets should fall under state gambling authority. It is a particularly contentious issue in states where sports betting is not legal, as platforms like Kalshi make huge profits from sports events contracts. These contracts account for around 80% of all activity on the platform, which regularly processes weekly volumes exceeding $4 billion.
There have been dozens of significant legal disputes, including actions by the Nevada Gaming Control Board against Kalshi. The court sided with the state regulator in its ruling earlier this year, ordering Kalshi to immediately stop what it deemed to be unlicensed gaming activities.
This story has been seen time and time again across the US. Arizona, Connecticut, and Illinois have all issued cease and desist orders against prediction platforms. Minnesota has taken things further, passing a statutory ban on operating or assisting prediction markets, effectively ordering them out of the state. It is the first state to pass such a ban, and may set a worrying precedent for platforms. New York and Maryland are the latest states to have banned state employees from using prediction sites, over concerns around insider trading.
Despite such rulings, the CFTC maintains that event contracts listed on federally regulated exchanges fall exclusively under its authority. It is, however, requesting public input on public-interest determinations, including whether certain categories of events should be prohibited from trading. It is also evaluating whether to amend core principles for exchanges and how to handle trading by individuals with asymmetric information. These questions indicate that the regulatory framework is still very much in flux.
It is clearly a tumultuous period for prediction markets. While they may be achieving financial success, platforms need to tread carefully to secure their futures. Further state bans could decimate the industry if no compromise is reached. Understandably, platforms want to make hay while the sun shines. With sports predictions the most profitable niche by a wide margin, platforms want to eke out every cent they can before they are forced to stop.
Nevertheless, prediction markets in the US are poised to evolve into a fully normalized financial infrastructure, with clearer CFTC rules, stronger federal oversight, and growing mainstream adoption. As platforms like Kalshi and Polymarket mature, they could expand into new offerings, even if they have to close others. The next phase hinges on federal-state resolution. Despite the strong regulatory headwinds, a future in which event contracts operate as regulated derivatives looks favorable.